I hadn’t been back to Toloache since it reopened after the pandemic. Like many other restaurants, their website prices are lower than you’ll pay.

We started with their yummy guac ($16) with the accompanying salsa ($2 for extra) and chips. Delicious with their Cadillac Margie—the Oro Blanco ($18), made with Espolon reposado and Cointreau.

Our dishes included their Ensalada de Jicama ($13), which included jicama, radishes, mixed greens, avocado, orange, almonds, and a tamarind vinaigrette, along with grilled chicken (+$8);  the
enchiladas borrachas ($26) of pulled chicken, tomatillo-5 chiles salsa, Mexican cheeses, crema and an avocado-radish salad and the Quesadilla de Camaron ($17) with mini shrimp atop a tortilla with  chile de arbol salsa, Chihuahua cheese with rice and beans.

We headed down the street to Circle in the Square to see Jeremy Strong in Enemy of the People, Revival of Henrik Ibsen’s powerful play.  We noticed Anna Wintour in the audience the day we attended!

Toloache
Midtown West
251 W 50th Street
New York, NY 10019
(212) 581-1818
toloachenyc.com/